‘The Mountain’ Oblivious To Controversy
Over Its Name
Rivalry was fierce in the early days of Washington and nowhere did it surface more strongly than in the debate over the official naming of “The Mountain.”
The dispute developed gradually. In 1792, George Vancouver, whose expedition was the first white group to see the peak, named it Mt. Rainier after a naval friend, Peter Rainier. The name was accepted by both English and American mapmakers.
Early settlers, however, frequently used some variation of the Indian name, Tacoma. For a long time, there was no argument.
Tacoma and Rainier were used interchangeably by settlers in both communities.
It wasn’t until 1883, that the Northern Pacific Railroad touched off the spark that started the feud. Their publication of March of that year announced: “The Indian name Tacoma will hereafter be used in the guide books and other publications... instead of Rainier.”
Seattleites rose up in protest, recognizing how much publicity this would give to their rival city to the south. Seattle papers accused Tacoma of a historical robbery, citing the right of discoverers to name things. Tacomans wanted to know who Rainier was, anyway.
Seattle said that if the people of Tacoma thought they could change the name of a mountain, next they’d try to rename the territory. A great idea, thought Tacoma, and in the next session of Congress they had Territorial Repre sentative Thomas Brents submit a bill to rename Washington Territory Tacoma if it became a state.
A Tacoma Academy of Science was created to gather unfavorable data about the name, career and personality of Peter Rainier and affidavits supporting the Indian use of Tacoma or Tahoma or Tacoba for the mountain.
The debate continued to rage through the formation of a national park encompassing the mountain. Senator Watson Squire’s bill proposing the park included, diplomatically, “Mount Rainier, often called Mount Tacoma.” Tacomans agreed the park could be called Mount Rainier National Park - but the mountain would still be Mount Tacoma.
Other good politicians were also careful to handle the matter tactfully. A prime example was the U.S. Vice President, speaking during President Grover Cleveland’s term of office in both Seattle and Tacoma in 1894. In all speeches, he concluded with “Ladies and gentlemen, there is no doubt in my mind what The Mountain should be called.”
Repeatedly, the issue was thrown to the U.S. Board on Geographic Names. Each time, it ruled in favor of Rainier. In the 1916 hearing, geologist C.H. Marriman pointed out that The Mountain was also know to Indian tribes as Stiquak and Puskehouse but nobody was pushing those Indian names.
The final hearing (to date) was in 1978, when the state Board on Geographic Names again reconsidered the recommendation to rename the mountain Mt. Tacoma. It remains Rainier.
Return to Index |